St John Inn
Best for travelers who want a small, budget-friendly boutique inn in walkable Cruz Bay with simple rooms, complimentary breakfast, beach gear, and an easy base for exploring St. John.
resort comparison guide
St John Inn vs Long Bay Beach Resort
Choosing between St John Inn and Long Bay Beach Resort? This in-depth comparison breaks down location, vibe, rooms, food, amenities, price & more so you can decide which stay is the best fit for your next Caribbean getaway.
Long Bay Beach Resort
Better for travelers who want a true beachfront resort experience on Tortola, with a more classic beach-vacation setting at Long Bay Beach Resort.
Quick Verdict: St John Inn vs Long Bay Beach Resort
If you want a casual, all-ages boutique stay in the heart of Cruz Bay, St John Inn is the more practical pick. It is not a full-service resort, but it works well for travelers who value walkability, ferry access, restaurants nearby, and included extras like breakfast, Wi-Fi, beach chairs, coolers, and snorkel gear.
If your priority is waking up at a beachfront resort on Tortola, Long Bay Beach Resort is the stronger fit. It gives you the more resort-style Caribbean escape, while St John Inn feels more like a charming in-town base for independent island days.
Bottom line: choose St John Inn for a small, affordable Cruz Bay boutique hotel with strong convenience; choose Long Bay Beach Resort for a beachfront Tortola resort atmosphere.
St John Inn vs Long Bay Beach Resort – At a Glance
| Category | St John Inn | Long Bay Beach Resort |
|---|---|---|
| Overall Vibe | Small, colorful, all-ages boutique inn with a casual Cruz Bay feel, friendly extras, and a practical home base style rather than a full resort setup. | Beachfront resort setting on Tortola, better suited to travelers who want their stay centered around the sand, sea, and a more traditional resort atmosphere. |
| Location | In Cruz Bay on St. John, within walking distance of restaurants, shopping, ferry docks, charter boats, and the National Park area. | On Long Bay in Tortola, giving it the edge for travelers who want a British Virgin Islands beachfront stay rather than an in-town St. John base. |
| Rooms & Suites | Simple rooms ranging from single rooms to two-room suites, with some kitchenettes and useful in-room amenities like refrigerators, microwaves, and coffee makers. | More resort-oriented accommodations for travelers choosing Tortola for a beach-focused stay at Long Bay Beach Resort. |
| Dining | Complimentary continental breakfast is included, plus a guest rum-punch happy hour; there is no full on-site restaurant for lunch or dinner. | Better fit if you want the dining experience tied more closely to a beachfront resort stay rather than relying primarily on walkable town restaurants. |
| Pools & Beach | One small outdoor pool and complimentary beach gear, but the inn itself is not beachfront; guests use it as a launch point for St. John beaches. | Beachfront setting is the main advantage, making it stronger for travelers who want sand and sea to be part of the resort itself. |
| Kids & Family | All-ages and family-friendly, with children welcome; best for independent families who want walkability, simple amenities, and easy access to Cruz Bay. | Works better for beach-focused families or couples who want more of a destination-resort setting on Tortola. |
| Price & Value | Best value for travelers who want a small, moderately priced St. John base with included breakfast, Wi-Fi, parking, and beach-day gear. | Best value for travelers who will get more out of a beachfront resort setting and want their stay to revolve around Long Bay. |
Rooms & Suites: Boutique Simplicity vs Beachfront Resort Style
St John Inn – Room Style
Rooms at St John Inn are simple, practical, and geared toward travelers who plan to spend much of the day out exploring. The inn offers room types from single rooms to two-room suites, with some kitchenettes and convenient basics for a low-key island stay.
- Rooms range from single rooms to two-room suites
- Some accommodations include kitchenettes for added flexibility
- In-room conveniences include refrigerators, microwaves, coffee/tea makers, and Wi-Fi
St John Inn is the better pick if you want a small, practical Cruz Bay base rather than a large resort room experience.
Long Bay Beach Resort – Room Style
Long Bay Beach Resort is the more natural choice if you want accommodations connected to a beachfront resort atmosphere. Compared with St John Inn, it feels less like an in-town stopover and more like the place where you settle in for the beach portion of the trip.
- Better suited to travelers who want a resort-style stay
- Strong fit for guests prioritizing beachfront atmosphere
- Best for couples or families who want the hotel setting to feel like the vacation itself
If your room choice is mostly about being part of a beach resort setting, Long Bay Beach Resort has the stronger appeal.
Dining & Drinks: Walkable Cruz Bay Options vs Resort-Based Beach Stay
St John Inn – Breakfast & Guest Perks
St John Inn keeps dining simple. A complimentary continental breakfast is served daily, and the inn is known for a complimentary sunset rum-punch happy hour for guests. For lunch and dinner, the appeal is being close to Cruz Bay restaurants rather than dining on property.
Expect:
- Complimentary continental breakfast with simple morning staples
- Complimentary guest rum-punch happy hour on the deck or poolside
- No full on-site restaurant, so dinners are best planned in Cruz Bay
Long Bay Beach Resort – Restaurants & Bars
Long Bay Beach Resort is the better fit if you want meals and drinks to feel more connected to a beachfront resort stay. It suits travelers who prefer lingering by the beach instead of using the hotel mainly as a walkable base.
- More natural fit for a beach-resort dining rhythm
- Better for travelers who want to stay close to the sand during the day
- Ideal if your priority is a resort atmosphere over town-based dining flexibility
If walkable restaurant choice matters most, St John Inn has the edge; if beachfront resort ambiance matters more, Long Bay Beach Resort is the better match.
Pools & Beach: Small Cruz Bay Pool vs Long Bay Beachfront
St John Inn – Pool & Beach Scene
St John Inn has one small outdoor pool, plus complimentary beach chairs, coolers, towels, and snorkel gear for guests. It is not a beachfront hotel, so the beach experience is more about heading out for the day from Cruz Bay.
- One small outdoor pool on property
- Complimentary beach chairs, coolers, and snorkel gear for off-property beach days
- Best for travelers who are comfortable using the inn as an island base
Long Bay Beach Resort – Pool & Beach Scene
Long Bay Beach Resort wins for travelers who want the beach to be central to the stay. Its Tortola beachfront setting gives it a stronger vacation-resort feel than St John Inn's in-town Cruz Bay location.
- Beachfront setting on Long Bay
- Better for slow beach days without leaving the resort area
- Stronger choice for travelers who prioritize sand-and-sea scenery
If you want a beachfront resort experience, Long Bay Beach Resort is the clear winner; if you want beach access through day trips and included gear, St John Inn works well.
Kids & Family: Casual All-Ages Inn vs Beach Resort Escape
St John Inn – Family-Friendly Convenience
St John Inn is an all-ages, family-friendly property where children are welcome. It does not offer a big kids-club resort setup, but it can work well for families who want simple accommodations, walkability, and included gear for beach days.
- Children of all ages are welcome
- Kids 12 and under can stay free using existing bedding
- Best for independent families who want Cruz Bay convenience
Long Bay Beach Resort – Family & Couples Appeal
Long Bay Beach Resort is a better fit for families or couples who want the trip to feel more like a self-contained beach escape. The main advantage is the beachfront setting rather than the in-town flexibility that defines St John Inn.
- Strong for travelers who want beach time built into the property setting
- Better for couples seeking a classic Caribbean resort atmosphere
- Appealing for families who prefer a beach-resort base over a town inn
If your group wants walkability and a casual St. John base, choose St John Inn; if the group wants a beachfront resort feel, Long Bay Beach Resort is stronger.
Price & Value: Which Caribbean Stay Feels More Worth It?
St John Inn – Value Snapshot
St John Inn offers the most value when you want St. John convenience without paying for a large resort experience. The included breakfast, happy hour, Wi-Fi, parking, and beach gear add real usefulness for travelers who spend days exploring.
- Best for travelers who want a modest, walkable Cruz Bay base
- Great if you value included breakfast, Wi-Fi, parking, and beach gear
- Strong value for independent couples, families, and friends who do not need a full-service resort
Long Bay Beach Resort – Value Snapshot
Long Bay Beach Resort is the better value if you will make full use of its beachfront setting. For travelers who want a resort-style Tortola stay, the location itself is the main reason to choose it over a small in-town inn.
- Best for travelers who want a true beach resort atmosphere
- Stronger for couples or families planning slower days by the water
- Worth it if beachfront setting matters more than walkable town convenience
Who Wins? Best Caribbean Hotel by Travel Style
Best for Walkable Cruz Bay Convenience
St John Inn
Choose St John Inn if you want an all-ages, low-key boutique hotel in Cruz Bay with easy walking access to restaurants, shopping, ferry docks, and island excursions.
Best for Beachfront Resort Atmosphere
Long Bay Beach Resort
Long Bay Beach Resort is the better pick if you want a beachfront Tortola resort setting and a stay that feels centered on the beach from the moment you arrive.
Best for Independent St. John Exploring
St John Inn
For travelers who like to explore during the day and return to a simple, friendly base with breakfast, happy hour, and beach gear included, St John Inn makes more sense.
Best for Sand-and-Sea Vacation Style
Long Bay Beach Resort
If your ideal trip is more about a classic Caribbean resort atmosphere, beachfront scenery, and slower days on Long Bay, choose Long Bay Beach Resort.
BOOK YOUR STAY NOW
Questions? Contact Us!
- Agents Available 24/7
- Lowest Price Guaranteed
- Complimentary Perks & Upgrades
- Agents Available 24/7
- Lowest Price Guaranteed
- Complimentary Perks & Upgrades
More St John Inn Guides
Explore more helpful planning guides and insider articles for St John Inn:
- St John Inn vs The Ritz-Carlton, St. Thomas
- St John Inn vs The Westin St. John Resort Villas
- St John Inn vs The Westin St. Thomas Beach Resort & Spa
- St John Inn vs Margaritaville Vacation Club St. Thomas
- St John Inn vs Secret Harbour Beach Resort
- St John Inn vs Scrub Island Resort, Spa & Marina
- St John Inn vs Peter Island Resort
- St John Inn vs Bolongo Bay Beach Resort
- St John Inn vs Wyndham Tortola BVI Lambert Beach Resort
- St John Inn vs Emerald Beach Resort
- St John Inn vs Point Pleasant Resort
- St John Inn vs Club Wyndham Elysian Beach Resort
- St John Inn vs Sapphire Beach Resort
- St John Inn vs Limetree Beach Resort by Club Wyndham
- St John Inn vs Cane Garden Bay Beach Hotel
- St John Inn vs Sebastian's on the Beach
- St John Inn vs Sugar Mill hotel
- St John Inn vs Buoy Haus Beach Resort St. Thomas, Autograph Collection