St John Inn – Room Style

Rooms at St John Inn are practical, casual, and geared toward travelers who want a comfortable base rather than a luxury resort Suite. Accommodations range from single rooms to two-room suites, with some kitchenettes available.

• Room options range from single rooms to two-room suites
• Some accommodations include kitchenettes for added convenience
• In-room amenities include refrigerators, microwaves, coffee/tea makers, hair dryers, and premium bedding

St John Inn is the better pick if you want a simple, walkable, all-ages Cruz Bay stay with useful in-room basics and a casual boutique feel.

Point Pleasant Resort – Room Style

Point Pleasant Resort leans more toward a villa-style resort experience, with an ocean-view setting that suits travelers who want more of a retreat feel than a town inn.

• Villa-style accommodations with a stronger resort feel
• Better for travelers who prioritize ocean views over town walkability
• Best for guests who want a quieter, more spacious-feeling stay

If you want an ocean-view villa atmosphere and a more traditional resort-style experience, Point Pleasant Resort is likely the better fit.

St John Inn – Pool & Beach Gear

St John Inn has one small outdoor pool, but its stronger beach advantage is practical: guests can use complimentary snorkel gear, beach chairs, beach towels, and coolers when heading out for the day.

• One small outdoor pool on property
• Complimentary snorkel gear, beach chairs, towels, and coolers
• Best for travelers who plan to explore St. John’s beaches rather than stay poolside all day

Point Pleasant Resort – View-Focused Resort Setting

Point Pleasant Resort is the better choice if you want the scenery and feel of an ocean-view resort stay to be a bigger part of the trip.

• Stronger for travelers who want a resort-style setting
• Better if ocean views are central to the vacation
• A good fit for guests who prefer staying put and soaking in the setting

If you want a simple pool plus gear for beach-hopping, choose St John Inn; if you want the property itself to feel more scenic and resort-like, choose Point Pleasant Resort.

St John Inn – Family-Friendly Basics

St John Inn is an all-ages, family-friendly property where children are welcome. It is best for families who want a casual Cruz Bay base, simple included perks, and easy access to restaurants, shops, and ferries.

• Children of all ages are welcome
• Kids 12 and under stay free in the same room using existing bedding
• Best for families who value walkability and practical amenities over a large resort program

Point Pleasant Resort – Family & Group Fit

Point Pleasant Resort is a better fit for families or small groups who prefer villa-style accommodations and a quieter, more residential resort feel.

• Good for travelers who want more of a retreat-style stay
• Better for couples, families, or groups who prioritize views and space
• Stronger if being in the middle of Cruz Bay is not the main goal

If your family wants walkable Cruz Bay convenience, St John Inn is the simpler choice; if you want a villa-style resort setting, Point Pleasant Resort is the better match.

St John Inn – Value Snapshot

St John Inn offers the most value when you want a small, friendly, well-located base with included extras. It is especially strong for travelers who plan to spend their days exploring and want to keep the hotel experience simple.

• Best for travelers who want Cruz Bay walkability
• Great if you value free breakfast, Wi-Fi, self-parking, and beach gear
• Strong value for guests who do not need an on-site restaurant, spa, gym, or large resort pool

Point Pleasant Resort – Value Snapshot

Point Pleasant Resort is the better value if your priorities are ocean views, villa-style accommodations, and a more resort-like environment.

• Best for travelers who want a scenic resort setting
• Stronger for guests who prefer villa-style space over a small inn layout
• Worth it if ocean-view atmosphere matters more than walkable town convenience